What is a fact? How true does a fact need to be for a writer composing a non-fiction essay for a topnotch literary magazine? This is the question that is continuously debated in the play The Lifespan of a Fact. The plot focuses on John D’Agata (Shannon Michael Wamser), a writer full of bluster and conceit, who is having his latest piece fact-checked by Jim Fingal (Edward Montoya), a magazine’s intern, and recent Harvard graduate full of bravado, at least at first. D’Agata is none too happy about the young man’s constant questions into his literary license. When Fingal decides to fly to the writer’s Las Vegas home to personally confront him with his 130-page spreadsheet of errors, fireworks erupt. Trying to referee the twosome’s hostility towards each other and their constant quarreling is the magazine’s editor, Emily Penrose (Suzanne O’Donnell). She has a hard fast deadline rapidly approaching as she decides how far her star writer can push the envelope in matters of journalistic integrity.
The play is based on a 2012 book by the real-life D’Agata and Fingal about the essayist’s account of a suicide in Las Vegas. Playwrights Jeremy Kareken, David Murrell, and Gordon Farrell have turned the source material into an illuminating point-counter point on the nature of non-fiction writing. The show is funny, at times, but the overt message is serious and one that, to this day, continually disputed. On the one hand, the character of D’Agata sees nothing wrong with bending facts to his storytelling. On the other hand, Fingal is just as determined to insist on factual accuracy. Director Matt Pfeiffer subtly triangulates the three combatants around the stage as each asserts their own interpretation of a fact. While the on-going arguments bring up fascinating points, the problem is how some “facts” are given the same weight as others. For example, the bricks of a building should be brown, not red. However, is that the same magnitude of seriousness as changing a teenage girl’s method of suicide to hanging from jumping off a building?
Shannon Michael Wamser brings braggadocio tinged with anger to the character of John D’Agata. What is missing is a swashbuckling demeanor to go with his brashness. Suzanne O’Donnell’s sharply layers the role of Emily Penrose with purpose, uncertainty, and forcefulness. Edward Montoya brings a convincing mix of emotions and traits to the character of Jim Fingal. Lively and combative one minute, reserved and unsure the next. His portrayal of an intern starting out in the world of magazine publishing is credible and persuasive.
Scenic Designer Patti Panyakaew’s collapsable set is ingenious as the performance space almost instantly transforms from a sleek office to the humble living room and kitchen area of D’Agata’s unassuming abode.
The Lifespan of a Fact, playing at Playhouse on Park through May 3. Click here for dates, times and ticket information.



























