Operation Mincemeat - Broadway

I have been a fan of the musical Operation Mincemeat ever since I heard the original cast recording almost two years ago.  However, I had some trepidation before seeing the show once it opened on Broadway.  Fortunately, any concerns were short-lived.  Operation Mincemeat is wild, manic, and exhaustively inventive.  The show is the brainchild of the comedy troupe SpitLip and members David Cumming, Felix Hagan, Natasha Hodgson, and Zoë Roberts wrote the book, music, and lyrics.  The quartet takes their inspiration from such thoroughly British sources as Monty Python’s Flying Circus, Benny Hill, and the theatrical productions of The 39 Steps and The Play That Goes Wrong.

 

The plot is based on the real-life ploy by the British army to deceive the German forces into thinking the Allies would invade Sardina instead of Sicily during a critical moment in World War II.  How?  Simple.  Fake a crash landing of a British fighter jet with a corpse holding fake invasion plans and hope the papers find their way to the head of German command.  Spoiler Alert - it works.

 

The five-person cast, embodying multiple characters, utilizing minimal sets (Ben Stones) and a brisk story-telling modus operandi, blazes a path of comedic hijinks and ingenious theatrical gimmicks.  Robert Hastie is resourceful and extremely creative in his directing prowess.  He adeptly manages the numerous quick character turnarounds and shows a skillfulness with handling the physical and verbal comedy.  The phone sequence outside the Spanish Coroner’s Office is a gem of mayhem and laughs.  Choreographer Jenny Arnold contributes upbeat numbers that add a dash of splash to the production.

 

The score is tuneful, funny and, at times, touching.  The character Hester Leggat’s (Jak Malone) song, “Dear Bill,” a fictional love letter she dictates to be included with the dead man’s personnel effects, leaves nary a dry eye in the house.  Conversely, the aptly named “Glitzy Finale” pulls out all the stops for, well, a glitzy sendoff.

 

The cast, which plays with swapping gender roles, is zany and altogether amusing.  Still, while jocularity reigns supreme, their primary portrayals are well-grounded as they push the story forward.   Three members of SpitLip are also in the musical - David Cumming, Natasha Hodgson, and Zoë Roberts.  The aforementioned Jak Malone and Claire-Marie Hall, round out the superb cast.

 

With all the accolades, there is one glaring issue with Operation Mincemeat – Mike Walker’s Sound Design.  When the full cast sings, the lyrics are almost indecipherable due to the mix between the vocals and band.   In addition, besides Ms. Hall, the other performers don’t come across as trained singers.  All of this is demonstrably obvious in the Act II opening number “Uber Mensch,” which is loud and just about incoherent.

 

Operation Mincemeat, extended through February 2026, playing at the Golden Theater on Broadway.