The musical The Snow Goose, receiving its world-premiere at the Goodspeed Opera House, is based on the beloved 1940 novella of the same name. It is an intimate tale of friendship and the cyclical nature of life.

The cast of The Snow Goose. Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
In the book, Philip, an artist, lives in an abandoned lighthouse, afraid to interact with others because of his disability. He is befriended by a local girl, Fritha, who brings a wounded snow goose to him to nurse back to health. Once the snow goose has healed, she returns each year to be at the side of Philip and Fritha. At the end of the story, Philip volunteers his boat to be part of the famous Dunkirk evacuation of British troops during WW II, risking his life for others and, in the process, saving numerous lives.

Ashlyn Maddox and Eric Graise in The Snow Goose. Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
The Goodspeed production has enlarged this simple tale, adding many new characters and plot points not found in the book. The resulting, expanded musical comes across as overstuffed with side plots, and characters not fully developed. The results are mostly unsatisfying and ends up diluting the central themes of the book.
The show begins with The Bard, a troubadour (a new character), acting as a type of narrator, setting the scene for what will occur. Fritha, who now has three friends – Wilf, Clara, and Farley (all new characters) – gets separated while exploring the marshes of Essex, England. Fritha finds a wounded snow goose and brings it to the lighthouse where, according to townsfolk, “the monster” resides. There resides Philip, a double amputee, who grudgingly agrees to nurse the bird. This begins a tentative, then lasting friendship between the two as the snow goose returns each year during her migratory journey.
Matthew Davies, Leah Hofmann,
Kiersten Kelly and the cast of The Snow Goose.
Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
In between the yearly reunions, trouble brews for Fritha as her aunt (new character), who has raised her since she was a child, forbids the young girl from seeing Philip. Wilf, her would-be boyfriend, also disallows her from visiting the lighthouse. Ignoring their edicts, Fritha clandestinely continues her rendezvouses. Fritha urges Philip to come to town to show the towns folk he is not a monster, but when he arrives he is verbally and physically assaulted because he is different. Later, when boatmen are recruited to help save soldiers at Dunkirk, Philp pushes aside the hate and prejudice heaped upon him to volunteer, sacrificing his life in the process.

Ashlyn Maddox in The Snow Goose. Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
The central issue with the book by Scott Gilmour and Claire McKenzie is the inclusion of so much additional material that blunts the unadorned earnestness of the source material. Storylines are not fully fleshed out, and characters are not completely developed. There is now a large ensemble, with uneven choreographic flourishes by Misha Shields, filling the stage. Emmie Finckel’s Scenic Design are at its best when the staging is minimal. Philip’s sailboat is especially well-done.
The strength of the Snow Goose is the performance of Eric Graise as Philip and the puppeteers manipulating the snow goose. Graise, a double amputee, adds a high degree of realism to the Goodspeed stage. He effortlessly exudes strength, independence, and melancholy in his role. The snow goose has been designed by Nicholas Mahon and manipulated, primarily by Leah Hofmann. The puppet comes alive within the practiced arms of his handlers, exuding playfulness, joy, and fear.

Ally Bonino and the cast of The Snow Goose. Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
Ashlyn Maddox’s Fritha is at her best as a young lass, struggling with her own feelings and the decisions she wants to make. The actress is less successful as she ages, a full ten years by the musical’s conclusion. While a forceful presence on stage as Harper, Fritha’s aunt, Ally Bonino is not given enough of a backstory to establish her character beyond a nagging relative. Out of the new characters, Charlie Webb’s Wilf receives significant stage time. He brings youthful energy, timid emotions, and a degree of intimidation to his portrayal.
The score by Scott Gilmour and Claire McKenzie can be unabashedly exuberant and reflective. There are some Broadway styled songs, but the majority of the numbers are tinged with the folk music of the area.

Eric Graise and Ashlyn Maddox in The Snow Goose. Photo by Diane Soboelwski.
Director Marshall Pailet, who helmed the outstanding musical Private Jones at the Norma Terris Theatre a few seasons ago, works hard attempting to make all the diverse elements of the show coalesce into an entertaining whole. He partially succeeds, with the more intimate scenes involving Philip, Fritha, and, to some extent, the snow goose – as a prime example.
The Snow Goose, playing at the Goodspeed Opera House through October 18. Click here for dates, times, and ticket information.















